Standard Notation vs. Tablature – Do I really need both?
Music for guitar is usually written in one of two ways—standard notation (SN hereafter, for the sake of brevity), or tablature (tab, for short). A never-ending controversy regarding SN and tab is, “Can you be a real guitarist if you only know tab?”
Some beginners may not be familiar with either SN or tab, so let’s cover some background before we dive into the discussion:
What is Tablature?
Guitar tab consists of a staff of six horizontal, parallel lines, one to represent each string, with the high e on the top and low E on the bottom. (A lower case “e” is commonly used to denote the high e string, and capital “E” denotes the low E string.) A number placed on a line indicates which fret to press on that particular string. So a number 7 on the third line from the top would mean to press the 7th fret on the G string. Here is an
example of guitar tab.
What is Standard Notation?
SN uses a five-line staff, and round-headed notes are placed on the lines and in the spaces between the lines. Various note stems are used to indicate the duration of the note, and other symbols are used to indicate rests (pauses), etc. Here is a
sample of SN. Ha! Just kidding. Here is a
real sample of SN for guitar. (Don't be intimidated by what you see--it's not a beginner's piece.)
Pros and Cons of Tab
Tab has the advantage of being very easy to learn, giving a quick start to those who don’t know SN. Another advantage of tab has to do with specific placement of a note on the fretboard. On a guitar, the same note (pitch) can be played multiple places on the fretboard. For example, play the 9th fret of the D string, then play the 4th fret of the G string, then play the open B string. You have just played the same B note in each of three positions. Tab tells you exactly which place to play the note.
The most obvious disadvantage of tab is that it gives no information about rhythm, or length of time to hold each note. Unless the song is familiar and you know how it is supposed to sound, you must have a recording or someone to play it for you, in order to emulate the rhythm and learn it.
The Myth
A number of well-known professional guitarists know only tab and don’t read SN. So the myth persists that knowing tab alone is enough, and that there is no compelling reason to go to the trouble of learning SN. The thing is, the previously-mentioned highly-successful guitarists also usually have years of experience and a very well-developed ear, and can play along without any written page in front of them once they know the key and the style of music. Most beginning guitarists do not yet have this skill of “playing by ear.”
Pros and Cons of Standard Notation
SN also has pros and cons. On the plus side, SN helps a guitarist develop an understanding of theory, including melody, harmony, keys, etc. SN has the advantage in illustrating the relationships between notes, such as the intervals (e.g. thirds, fifths, octaves), and in showing how chords are built. SN provides detailed information about rhythm, rests, dynamics, and duration of each note, which tab does not.
A guitarist who knows SN can take a piece of music written for another instrument (e.g., piano or voice) and play along with it. Not true for the tab-only reader. It is virtually a requirement that all studio, or session, musicians read SN.
The main disadvantage of SN is actually seen by some (usually more experienced guitarists) as an advantage, and that is this: SN does not provide any advice about where on the fretboard to play a given note. That leaves it up to the discretion of (and requires some knowledge on the part of) the guitarist.
Reciting vs. Speaking the Language
Banjo player and educator “Dr. Banjo” Peter Wernick equates learning how to play from tablature alone (without SN) with the difference of learning to “recite,” when one should be learning how to “speak” the language. He says he’s also seen this with ESL adults learning to read English. Sometimes they are “fluent,” though they don’t actually know how to put together a sentence on their own.
The Best of Both Worlds
While a guitarist can learn to play well using tab alone, making the extra effort to learn SN will result in improved skills and musicianship in the long run. It is doubtful that many have ever regretted learning SN once they understood what it can do. Knowing how to read and use both tab and SN is the best of both worlds.
Due to years of playing the piano I already knew how to read SN before picking up the guitar. I have come to the point where I will only purchase guitar books that have both SN and tab, so I can use the best of both. I can read the tab faster than I can read SN, but I need the SN especially to learn the rhythm initially. Also, I can take the SN to my piano and play it through, so I have an idea what an unfamiliar song is supposed to sound like.
If you’re ready to start learning SN, here is an
excellent lesson on standard notation by Tom Serb, professional musician, composer, guitar teacher, and author of
Music Theory for Guitarists. Knock yourself out!